干旱区生态环境知识资源中心(Arid): Comparison of seven simple loss models for runoff prediction at the plot, hillslope and catchment scale in the semiarid southwestern US

Arid

DOI	10.1016/j.jhydrol.2021.126490
	Comparison of seven simple loss models for runoff prediction at the plot, hillslope and catchment scale in the semiarid southwestern US
	Schoener, Gerhard; Stone, Mark C.; Thomas, Charles
通讯作者	Schoener, G (corresponding author), Southern Sandoval Cty Arroyo Flood Control Author, 1041 Commercial Dr SE, Rio Rancho, NM 87124 USA.
来源期刊	JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY
ISSN	0022-1694
EISSN	1879-2707
出版年	2021
卷号	598
英文摘要	Infiltration excess overland flow is the dominant mechanism for runoff generation in many dryland watersheds. Event-based rainfall-runoff models therefore partition precipitation into two components: loss and excess precipitation. The latter is then transformed into a runoff hydrograph. Numerous loss models have been developed over the past century ranging from simple empirical to sophisticated physically based methods. Complex models can lead to equifinality and associated uncertainty at larger spatial scales with varying soil and cover conditions. Simple models are therefore widely used in hydrologic practice. In the absence of measured data in many arid and semiarid regions, model parameters are often estimated based on laboratory or field infiltrometer tests. Given the documented importance of spatial scale on the runoff response in dryland catchments, it is not clear how models parameterized at the point or soil column scale will perform at the hillslope or catchment scale under real-world conditions. In this study, we compared the performance of seven simple loss models with three or less parameters: the Philip, Smith-Parlange, Horton, Kostiakov, curve number (CN), initial and constant (IC) and the linear and constant (LC) models. The latter is a modification of the IC model introduced in this study. We estimated parameters at the plot scale (2.8 m(2)) using rainfall simulation and then tested model performance at the hillslope (1.5-3.7 ha) and catchment scale (2.4-2.8 km(2)) based on measured rainfall-runoff data at two sites in New Mexico and Arizona, U.S. Results show that rainfall simulation can be used successfully to parameterize loss models at the hillslope scale. At the catchment scale, most models showed positive bias, suggesting that other losses (such as channel or transmission losses) play an important role in determining the catchment runoff response. Rainfall intensity and temporal distribution were found to be crucial for accurate runoff prediction. Models that are sensitive to rainfall intensity during the entire simulation (Philip, Smith-Parlange, Horton, Kostiakov, LC) therefore performed better than those with an initial abstraction term (CN, IC). During intermittent rain, the best results were achieved by methods expressing infiltration capacity as a function of cumulative infiltration (LC, Smith-Parlange).
英文关键词	Infiltration Runoff Semiarid Spatial Scale Rainfall Simulation
类型	Article
语种	英语
收录类别	SCI-E
WOS记录号	WOS:000661813200201
WOS关键词	PORTABLE RAINFALL SIMULATOR ; ANTECEDENT SOIL-MOISTURE ; SPATIAL VARIABILITY ; INFILTRATION MODELS ; OVERLAND-FLOW ; INTENSITY ; GENERATION ; EROSION
WOS类目	Engineering, Civil ; Geosciences, Multidisciplinary ; Water Resources
WOS研究方向	Engineering ; Geology ; Water Resources
资源类型	期刊论文
条目标识符	http://119.78.100.177/qdio/handle/2XILL650/368658
作者单位	[Schoener, Gerhard; Thomas, Charles] Southern Sandoval Cty Arroyo Flood Control Author, 1041 Commercial Dr SE, Rio Rancho, NM 87124 USA; [Stone, Mark C.] Univ New Mexico, Dept Civil Construct & Environm Engn, Albuquerque, NM 87131 USA
推荐引用方式 GB/T 7714	Schoener, Gerhard,Stone, Mark C.,Thomas, Charles. Comparison of seven simple loss models for runoff prediction at the plot, hillslope and catchment scale in the semiarid southwestern US[J],2021,598.
APA	Schoener, Gerhard,Stone, Mark C.,&Thomas, Charles.(2021).Comparison of seven simple loss models for runoff prediction at the plot, hillslope and catchment scale in the semiarid southwestern US.JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY,598.
MLA	Schoener, Gerhard,et al."Comparison of seven simple loss models for runoff prediction at the plot, hillslope and catchment scale in the semiarid southwestern US".JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY 598(2021).